The 10 Best American-Made Dog Toys of 2023 – Reviews & Top Picks

After looking for dog toys sourced from various regions across the globe, we give you unbiased reviews of the best American-made dog toys that are reliable for their premium quality and safety.

Dog toys are manufactured across various countries and each of them has a different quality and is made of different raw materials.

However, these toys are not very safe and reliable for your pet as they may contain toxic dyes, harmful chemicals, and unwanted fillers. Instead of encouraging playfulness, the toy may end up being dangerous for your pet.

In such cases, the best option is to rely on Made in USA Dog Toys. These are safe, made of a known composition of raw materials, and do not contain any toxic substances or allergic metals.

The best part about the USA made toys is they are locally sourced which encourages small scale industries and USA based companies as well as contributes to their overall well-being.

Therefore, we decided to help you give your fido the best dog toys made in the USA by reviewing the top American Dog Toy Picks of 2023.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2023

• Best Overall: KONG Durable Classic Dog Toy at Amazon
• Premium Choice: Goughnuts Maxx Large Dog Chew Toys at Amazon
• Best Affordable: Benebone Durable Dog Chew Toy at Amazon

The 10 Best American-Made Dog Toys of 2023

1. KONG Durable Classic Dog Toy — Best Overall

The KONG Durable Classic Dog Toy is the best dog toy made in the U.S.A. as it mentally stimulates your dog and also satisfies their taste buds. You can add some exciting treats inside the toy to surprise your pet.

The toy can be tossed, bounced, and played with, and once your dog’s done playing, he can lick onto his share of treats merrily. It keeps him excited and on his toes all the time.

It is made of durable quality rubber that is suitable for aggressive chewers while KONG is known for its long-lasting range of chew and fetch toys.

The shape and design of the toy cause an unpredictable bounce in any direction. You can stuff the toy with treats, snacks or your dog’s favorite wet meal.

Your dog can lick and savor the taste of his treat with the toy while it also encourages slow feeding in your pet. Since it is made in the USA, the raw materials and processes used are quite reliable with no compromise in quality.

To conclude, we think this is the overall best american made dog toys.

Key Features:

• Size: Extra Large
• Material: Natural Rubber
• Type: Chew Toy/ Treat Dispensing Toy
• Suitable For: Medium and Large Breeds

However, pet parents claim that the dog toy has a very peculiar and strong rubber-like smell and is not delivered true to size which is a major put-off. Else, KONG has always been a trusted and reliable toy brand for years.

2. Goughnuts Maxx Large Dog Chew Toys — Premium Choice

The Goughnuts Maxx Large Dog Chew Toys is a premium quality best American made dog toy as it uses a very hard quality rubber that is used in spaceships and aircraft and is preferred by astronauts.

The toy is known to be of a very tough and durable quality.

There are multiple types of rubber based on your dog’s chewing intensity as well as varied size options available.

After intense studies and understanding, Goughnuts formulated a chew toy so that your pup gets maximum leverage to keep their jaws open and for mouth movement. This helps in keeping their oral and dental health intact.

The toy consists of PRO 50 rubber which is the toughest form of rubber and does not float on water.

The core has a red-colored safety indicator and if your dog starts chewing onto the upper layers and reaches the core to expose the red color, then it indicates that the toy needs to be replaced.

Key Features:

• Size: Large
• Material: Reinforced Natural Rubber
• Type: Chew Toy
• Suitable For: Medium and Large Breeds

The toy smells like raw rubber that has a peculiar smell. Moreover, the toy is quite highly-priced for its size and minimal features.

The rubber feels very hard to chew onto at first and can end up damaging your dog’s teeth. Else, it is quite a good toy for aggressive chewers.

3. Benebone Durable Dog Chew Toy — Best Affordable

Shoo anxiety and boredom away from your pet with the Benebone Durable Dog Chew Toy that is our best budget American made dog toy.

It is available in an amazing flavor of real bacon which makes a delightful treat and chews toy for your pet. These are tougher than real bones and can last for weeks.

The toy does not involve the use of any artificial flavors and includes pure bacon, chicken, or peanut, all of which are known to be pure doggy favorites. The shape and the design of the toy are such that it is easy to grip for your pet.

The quality dog toy lasts for weeks and is quite budget-friendly in spite of being made from high-quality materials sourced from the USA.

No materials or manufacturing processes are carried out in China making it quite safe. The chew bone literally looks like a real bone, just a lot tastier and long-lasting.

Key Features:

• Size: Small
• Material: Nylon with bacon flavor
• Type: Chew Toy
• Suitable For: Medium and Large Breeds

However, these bones are too hard to chew onto as claimed by dog parents and not very suitable for small to medium dog breeds or even teething puppies. Choose to buy this one, only if your dog is one heck of an aggressive chewer.

4. West Paw Zogoflex Zisc Dog Frisbee – Made in USA

Its aerodynamic design and lightweight body make the WestPaw Zogoflex Zisc Dog Frisbee a fun and enjoyable toy for your active pet.

It is built to last long and is an incredibly durable yet soft dog toy. The bright colors make it easy to spot anywhere in the bushes or on the couch.

The dog toy even bounces and flies across larger distances. It is made of Zogoflex material which makes it extremely durable, recyclable, dishwasher safe, as well as floatable. All Zogoflex toys are made in the USA and are also available for recycling.

The best part of the dog toy is that you can use it as food as well as a water bowl by simply flipping it and you can use this toy for picnics for multipurpose use.

The toy is also dishwasher safe and can be given a gentle cycle on the top rack. Convenient to use and play with, this dog toy is made of recyclable material that is latex-free and is 100% Made in the USA.

Key Features:

• Size: Medium
• Material: Flex Material
• Type: Soccer Toy, Exercise Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

Dog parents claim that the frisbee material starts wearing off from the center and starts tearing. It is not meant for aggressive breeds but holds up well for a game of fetch.

5. Jolly Pets Soccer Ball USA Made Dog Toy

The Jolly Pets Soccer Ball USA Made Dog Toy is very tough and does not deflate easily made for your dog to indulge in a game of soccer. The ball is made of flex material which means the ball would not lose its sturdiness in spite of deflating or puncturing.

The soccer ball is ideal for medium to large size pets and is around 6 inches in diameter. It can be used on land as well as in water so you can indulge in a game even in the pool with your pup.

It has a textured design over the body which makes it easy for your pet to grip the ball while playing.

The ball is quite bouncy so your pup can play fetch, jump, bounce, catch and chase the ball while playing.

Since the soccer ball is proudly made in the USA, it is quite reliable in terms of quality and safety. Jolly Pets also does this great deed of supporting organizations that provide shelter to dogs.

Key Features:

• Size: Medium
• Material: Flex Material
• Type: Soccer Toy, Exercise Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

However, the toy is not meant for aggressive breeds and barely lasts for a few days. It makes for an excellent pastime and exercise toy while you can enjoy playing football with your pup.

6. SmartPetLove Snuggle Puppy Behavioral Aid Toy

If you want to teach your pet to behave and not act whiny, then the SmartPetLove Snuggle Puppy Behavioral Aid Toy does wonders on your pet.

It helps in instilling habits like crate training and reduces negative behaviors like biting and chewing on random objects in your house.

The toy helps in reducing stress and anxiety in your pet as it has a very calming effect due to the pulsing heartbeat. You can easily instil some emotions and behavioral aspects in your pet by giving them plush and relaxing toys like the SnugglePuppy to play with.

The toy is also machine washable on a gentle load cycle and has proved to reduce anxiety in case your dog is scared of firecrackers or thunderstorms. If your dog is an aggressive pup, this toy helps to calm its nerves down.

Key Features:

• Size: Medium
• Material: Fleece Fabric with plastic heartbeating toy
• Type: Behavioural aid toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

There are various colors and types available and the heart beating device is battery operated. It does not last long and stops working within 2 days of constant use.

The heartbeat-like device functions very loudly which may even scare your small pup. However, for dogs who ain’t scared, it works as a great aid for behavior correction and understanding.

7. Katie’s Bumpers Original Dog Toy

Katie’s Bumpers Original Dog Toy is a great way to engage your dog into pulling and tugging and going by their natural instincts, they enjoy it equally. It is available in 2 attractive colors that make it easily visible and are very appealing to your pet.

It has a rope attached for you to grip and pull the toy easily. The toy is dishwasher safe and made out of recycled plastic.

It can be used for playing in the pool as the toy is extremely light making it easy to float in water. It can sustain strong tugging and pulling and is made of pet safe materials as well.

Key Features:

• Size: Small
• Material: Recycled Plastic
• Type: Tug Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

However, the toy is not meant for aggressive users and larger breeds who have a strong chewing grip. It looks very appealing but does not withstand extreme usage as claimed by users.

8. Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Diamond Plate Dog Ball – Made in USA

With its shiny features and attractive looks, the Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Diamond Plate Dog Ball is a durable and tough dog toy made in the USA.

It is free of any toxic materials and is BPA as well as Phthalate free. The product has been approved by FDA and is extremely safe for use.

The dog toy is bouncy as well as floats on water. It has been infused with natural mint oil to soothe and calm your dog of anxiety as well as attract your dog to use the toy.

This toy sure encourages playfulness and exercise in your pet for him to run across distances and enjoy playing fetch with you.

Key Features:

• Size: Medium
• Material: Rubber
• Type: Fetch Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

It has been made of recyclable material causing no environmental harm. The toy is dishwasher safe for top rack washing in normal mode.

However, the dog toy is not made for aggressive breeds and wears off pretty easily. Hence it needs to be used with extreme supervision.

9. Cycle Dog High Roller Ball Dog Toy

The Cycle Dog High Roller Ball Dog Toy is made of recycled material which is nothing but high durability Ecoclast material that is eco-friendly as well as dog friendly.

It has a super floaty material that allows the ball toy to float above the water surface making it easy for dogs to find the ball in a pool or other large water bodies.

The ball dog toy can engage your dog into hours of fun as it also has a squeaker inside which makes the toy very interactive. The attractive color instantly appeals to your dog and it is quite easy to grip due to the ridges on the surface.

Your dog indirectly reduces its carbon paw prints on the environment by playing with this dog toy as it is safe and non-toxic for the environment as well as your fur mate. The squeaker is a fun way to distract your pet too.

Key Features:

• Size: Small
• Material: Recycled Ecoclast
• Type: Chew Toy/ Treat Dispensing Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

However, it is dangerous for dogs with strong jaws as they would break the toy almost instantly. The dog toy is not suitable for large dogs but makes for a good product to play with within the water and small pools for pups.

10. SodaPup – Natural Rubber Chew Toy – Made in USA

The SodaPup – Natural Rubber Chew Toy is a very reliable and safe dog toy as it is made in the USA and has several health benefits to offer.

It prevents separation anxiety in pets and slows down their feeding when it comes to offering them treats. If your dog is destructive by nature, then you can give him the SodaPup can to chew onto for hours.

You can also use the toy as an element of distraction from digging and excessive barking as well as serve it as a chew toy when your dog should not be overeating.

It helps in weight management and prevents excessive gulping of food. You can also reward your dog using an attractive looking can.

The dog can toy is made of durable natural rubber and comes in multiple sizes and design variants. It complies with all environmental standards before manufacturing to not cause any harm to your pet or the environment.

Each chew toy is made of durable quality and helps in fighting boredom. It is also a suitable toy for teething pups.

Key Features:

• Size: Large
• Material: Natural Rubber
• Type: Chew Toy/ Treat Dispensing Toy
• Suitable For: Small and Medium Dog Breeds

The material of the rubber can is too tough and the product is not true to size as claimed by certain users. However, the amount of fun it offers your dog upon chewing is unbeatable.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Dog Toys Made in USA?

Here are the steps you must follow before choosing the best dog toys made in the USA:

Size

The dog toy you choose should be of an appropriate size to match your pet. Dogs will definitely not use the toy if it is not of an appropriate size and does not adjust as per their needs.

Choose a toy which is one or two inches smaller than your dog’s dimensions.

If you use a tiny toy for a large and ferocious dog breed, he may end up ingesting the toy that may cause unwanted complications. Therefore, compare the size of the toy with your dog’s size before you get one for your fido.

Material

Another important factor to consider while ordering a dog toy is the material it is made up of. Dog toys are ideally made of metal, rubber, plastic, or cloth based on the different types.

However, the material you choose totally depends upon the way your dog uses the toy.

Ideally, it should be durable and light in weight, and should not tear instantly due to constant pulling and tugging.

The best and the most durable material is considered to be rubber in dog toys, followed by plastic and then cloth. Therefore, choose a material based on your pup’s natural habits and tendencies.

Type

There are various types of dog toys available right from chew toys, puzzle toys, exercise toys, tug toys, cuddle toys, and fetch toys. Each toy encourages your dog either physically or mentally and keeps them engaged for a long time.

If your dog is a tough player, you can get him a rope or tug toy else a strong chew toy to calm his aggressiveness.

If he likes to engage in exercise and activities, you can get him a fetch toy or an exercise ball. If your dog is a couch potato, then you can engage him in puzzle toys to stimulate him mentally.

Each type has something in the store but you can choose one wisely based on your dog’s habits.

Design

Make sure to choose a toy that has a simple and basic design because that is what dogs prefer. Anything that is made too intricately and contains a lot of attachments and screws would complicate the design and make it difficult for your dog to play with.

Moreover, the small attachments and screws can also get ingested by mistake and cause unwanted complications in your pet. Toys should possess a design that is easy to hold and grip from their teeth.

For example, fetch toys and chew toys like balls and frisbees need to have a particular shape and design that makes it easy for dogs to hold through their mouth.

The basic and minimalistic design also helps you to clean the toy easily without putting extra effort into the corners and ridges.

Ease of Cleaning

Most dog toys can be cleaned using a mild soap and brush or simply be rinsed with the hands under running tap water. However, certain toys also claim to be dishwasher safe and can easily be tossed into the machine once in a week for ease of cleaning.

Check for labels and prints which clearly mention the washing instructions. Dog toys from the U.S.A. are generally made of rich quality materials that do not deteriorate upon cleaning or soaking continuously.

Manufacturing Label

Make sure to not get fooled by false labels and check for U.S.A. quality dog toys only.

There are some toy brands that originally belong to other countries but use false labels to trick people into purchasing their toys. These toys tend to contain fillers and cheap dyes or additives that can be dangerous for pets.

Hence it is advisable to purchase from reliable stores that sell the only U.S.A. made toys and not keep other dog toys that are of cheap quality.

Why Choose Dog Toys Made in USA?

While we always want to choose the best for our dogs, American-made dog toys are reliable and trusted by dog parents when it comes to buying dog toys.

What makes them so trending and trustworthy? We have listed a few reasons for you to find out.

Support Local Business

Since these are made in our hometown U.S.A., the toys belong to local businesses and are not sourced or imported internationally.

By purchasing toys made in the U.S.A., we can remain loyal and patriotic to our own industries and aid in their profit. Additionally, it is a great means to generate employment by encouraging upcoming small scale industries.

High Quality

U.S.A made toys, in fact, are known for their high quality and are specifically hunted by people as they are reliable.

The raw materials used in the manufacturing process are sourced from the U.S.A. and are assembled in state-of-the-art manufacturing units which makes them stand apart.

No Toxic Dyes & Additives

American Made Toys do not use any artificial dyes, colors, or additives in order to make the toy look appealing unlike toys from China and Hong Kong that do not bother about the quality.

The colors, dyes, or materials used are food-grade since they are aware that dogs may try to ingest or lick the toys while exploring and playing with them. Artificial dyes and colors may cause skin allergies and respiratory disorders.

Since the toys will remain in constant contact with your dog either through their mouth or skin, U.S.A. made dog toys ensure that there are no toxic substances used.

Reliable Chemical Composition

Be of any material like plastic, metal, or rubber, American dog toys do not contain any harmful metals or chemicals like lead, arsenic, or mercury in the making of the products.

Therefore, these toys do not cause any allergies and are extremely reliable and safe to use.

Quicker and Cheaper Shipping

Since these are sourced locally, the time and cost for shipping would be way less as compared to other toys that are imported.

The benefit, your dog gets to lay his paws on the toy at the earliest while you get to see him enjoy without waiting for the toy to get delivered.

FAQs for American-Made Dog Toys

1. Are dog toys from the USA durable?

Yes! Dog toys from the USA are very durable as they are made from high-quality raw materials that are also sourced from the USA and are known to be very tough, safe, and long-lasting for rough use.

Therefore, many dog parents prefer buying made in USA dog toys due to their standard quality and reliability.

2. What is the best material for USA made dog toys?

The best material for dog toys should be indestructible and last for years which include rubber, or nylon rope or double knit rope.

These materials can sustain extreme chewing and aggressive tugging and remain in use for quite some time in spite of rough handling.

3. How much for American-made dog toys?

American-made dog toys can cost anywhere between $10-$40 depending upon the size, type, quality, material, brand, and various other factors.

The best American made dog toy in a budget price would be the Benebone Durable Dog Chew Toy that costs around $8-$10.

A premium choice of American made dog toy would be the Goughnuts Maxx Large Dog Chew Toys that costs anywhere between $30-$35. The best USA made dog toy would be the Kong Classic Durable Dog Toy that costs around $20-$25.

4. What is the best American-made Dog Toy?

While dog toys made in America are of high quality, the best one would be the KONG Classic Durable Dog Toy that dispenses treats, is suitable for playing fetch, and comes with the KONG’s unbeatable durability and quality.

A premium quality chew toy would be the Goughnuts Maxx Large Dog Chew Toys that are made of tough and hard rubber which suits the most aggressive chewers.

The best American made dog toy on a budget would be the Benebone Durable Dog Chew Toy which is safer and long-lasting than a real bone combined with the tasty flavor of bacon.

Final Note

American made dog toys are cheaper, belong to better quality, contain premium raw materials and are made locally. These are safer and reliable for dogs and hence pet parents trust these toys for years now.

There are various benefits of purchasing dog toys from USA based manufacturers as they would cost less and not be exported from other countries.

Read our reviews on the best American made dog toys in order to purchase a premium range of collectibles for your fur-mate.

After all, what better way to support local industries than purchasing the USA made dog toys.